Rated 2 out of 5 by Anonymous from Too Loose Need to return them. The strap across the top isn’t snug enough to hold the sandal in place when walking.

Date published: 2025-05-28

Rated 5 out of 5 by Lovey from Love!! Love these!! Super comfy and super cute!! They look great with dresses, linen pants and shorts as well!!

Date published: 2025-05-25

Rated 5 out of 5 by Robinj1129 from Upgraded McKim Sandal I love the new McKim sandals. The new soft footbed doesn’t look like much but it makes a big difference. These sandals are comfortable to wear all day and night.

Date published: 2025-05-21

Rated 1 out of 5 by DT27 from Unhappy Customer I bought these sandals thinking the footbed was leather as I had a pair for many years that had broken from a lot of wear. When they arrived I was so disappointed I sent them back immediately due to the gold footbed it was too much gold for the sandal. Please bring back the leather footbed. I will not be buying in the future. Cheaper is not better!

Date published: 2024-09-21

Rated 5 out of 5 by Bam Bam from I love these sandals. I have very narrow feet and these fit me perfectly.

Date published: 2024-09-21

Rated 1 out of 5 by Erin from Narrow and uncomfortable Way too small, poorly put together and uncomfortable.

Date published: 2024-07-12

Rated 1 out of 5 by kimcjb143 from Please Bring Back Old McKim Sandals! I have worn the old McKim style of Lilly sandals for many years. These are no comparison. The footbed is slippery and uncomfortable. I felt unsteady in them. Also, they did not fit as well. I usually wear a size 9.5, and my toes were hanging off the side of these. I do not have a wide foot, so the dimensions must be off. A size larger would have been too long. These obviously are not a hit with your fan base, Lilly, so please bring back the classics. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

Date published: 2024-07-06

Rated 1 out of 5 by Julie from Very disappointed I had McKim sandals with leather sole and loved them so much I wore them out! Wanted to replace them, so I ordered this new style and I don't like them at all. Yuck! Shiny gold footbed and rubber sole looks SO cheap. I will definitely be returning them.

Date published: 2024-06-25